What Your Sunday School Never Told You -Being “Chosen” Was Never About Being Better
Somewhere along the way, chosenness got tangled up with favor, and favor quietly morphed into something else entirely.
Before long, chosen didn’t just mean called. It started to sound like special. And special has a way of drifting toward better, even when no one says that part out loud.
That shift doesn’t stay theoretical. It shapes how certain verses are taught and how people imagine themselves inside the story.
So when Scripture talks about Israel as God’s chosen people, or when the New Testament uses that same language for believers, it can start to sound like God playing favorites.
Like there’s a divine short list.
That reading creates problems almost immediately.
And it isn’t what the text is doing.
In Scripture, Being Chosen Comes With Weight
When Scripture talks about being chosen, the primary Hebrew word it uses is בָּחַר (bachar), which means to select or set apart for a purpose.
It’s an intentional choosing, but not a sentimental one. Bachar isn’t about favoritism or superiority. It’s about assignment. God chooses people, places, and even cities in order to entrust them with responsibility, not to elevate their status.
That’s why chosenness in the Bible so often comes with pressure, correction, and accountability. To be chosen is to be given something to carry, not something to boast about.
When God calls Israel chosen, He doesn’t hand them a badge. He gives them a responsibility. They are chosen to carry God’s name in the world and to live in a way that reflects His character. That calling brings a whole lot of pressure.
Being chosen doesn’t insulate Israel from difficulty. It places them smack dab in it.
Their story is marked by tension, failure, repentance, exile, and restoration. Rinse and repeat.
God doesn’t choose them so they can stand above everyone else. He chooses them so they can be seen. Their lives are meant to show what faithfulness looks like, even when it’s imperfect and costly.
It isn’t a reward, it’s an assignment.
Election Is About Purpose, Not Preference
One thing Sunday school rarely slowed down enough to explain is how election actually works in Scripture.
God’s choosing is functional. It’s about role, not rank.
Abraham is chosen so blessing can move outward through him. Israel is chosen so the nations can see what it looks like to live under God’s rule. Prophets are chosen so uncomfortable truth doesn’t stay buried.
None of those callings come with ease. They come with responsibility.
Being chosen never means God values others less. It means someone has been entrusted with a task that exists for the sake of others.
And Scripture never treats that like a flex.
Being Chosen Doesn’t Mean Being Let Off the Hook
If chosenness were about superiority, the Bible would read very differently.
Instead, it tells the truth.
Israel is chosen and still rebuked.
Moses is chosen and still barred from the land when obedience slips.
David is chosen and still confronted.
The early church is chosen and still corrected, sometimes sharply.
God does not say, “You’re chosen, so it doesn’t matter how you live.”
He says, “You’re chosen, so now it matters deeply.”
This status never cancels accountability. It intensifies it.
Why This Got Twisted So Easily
Sunday school needed simple categories, especially for kids.
Chosen started to sound like love, love began to resemble preference, and preference quietly turned into hierarchy.
When it becomes about status, it stops sounding like Scripture and starts sounding like a spiritual caste system.
The Bible’s version of chosen always moves outward. Our version tends to curl inward.
That difference matters more than we usually admit.
This Changes How You Read the Story
When you stop reading chosen as favoritism or exclusivity, the whole story opens up.
You begin to see God shaping people for the sake of others, and it becomes clear that calling is almost always tied to responsibility, not comfort. Election stops sounding like exclusion and starts looking like mission.
My Final Thoughts
Your Sunday school probably meant well. Mine did too.
But in Scripture, being chosen isn’t a gold star. It’s a calling that carries weight.
It doesn’t elevate people above others. It sends them out toward others.
Chosen isn’t a title you wear. It’s a position you stand in, one that brings visibility, accountability, and trust whether you’re ready for it or not.
And once you see that, chosenness stops feeding spiritual ego and starts asking harder questions about faithfulness.
Which, honestly, feels much more like the God of the Bible.
Bible Study Questions
How does Genesis 12 describe the purpose behind Abraham’s calling?
Where do you see chosen people being confronted or corrected in Scripture?
How does Jesus reshape the idea of chosenness in the Gospels?
Reflection Questions
How were you taught to understand the idea of being chosen?
Where have you seen chosenness framed as status rather than responsibility?
What shifts when you view calling as service instead of privilege?
Action Challenges
Read Genesis 12 and trace how blessing is immediately tied to others.
Notice how often Scripture connects calling with accountability.
Ask God where you’ve been entrusted with responsibility in this season.
If this study stirred something in you, share it with a friend who might need it too.
And if it left you wanting to go slower and deeper into the Word, there’s a place for that.
Inside The Vault, we go slower, deeper, and more intentionally into Scripture… moving from reading the Word to actually living it.
Paid subscribers get access to extended studies, devotionals. theological teaching, spiritual formation practices, and a community of women who want depth without pressure or performance.
If you’re ready to step further into the Word, you’re welcome inside.
If a paid subscription isn’t feasible right now but this space has blessed you, you can leave a one-time tip here. Every gift helps sustain this work. 🤍
This is excellent.
This is one ”hot” topic. I find it interesting that Adonai did not call me back to the church, He commanded my attendance at a Messianic shul.
It’s difficult for Christian leaders to understand that in 2021, hundreds of church people were called to “learn Torah”.
The prophetic role brings great responsibility and testing. It becomes an even greater challenge for females. The attitudes from pastors and rabbis toward women’s spiritual gifting are often negative.
I do not understand G-d’s appointments. Then again, His ways are not my ways. His thoughts are not my thoughts. I’m simply kept guessing.